Meet Our Team


Don Ritchey, President

Don joined the agency in 1998 after working 17 years with Motorists Insurance Group in Columbus. While working with Motorists, he gained experience in claims, marketing and underwriting. He graduated from Findlay College in 1981 with a Bachelor of Science in Business Management and is licensed in Property, Casualty, Life and Health. Don and his wife, Karla, are the proud parents of two grown sons, Heath and Lane.


Roger Tuttle, Insurance Advisor

Roger joined the agency in 1978 after working for Superior Coach for 13 years as the Sales Manager for the western part of the United States and Canada. He is a graduate of Waynesfield-Goshen High School and Columbus Business University. Roger and his wife, Joyce, are the parents of three children and have eight grandchildren.


Dan Zwiebel, Insurance Advisor

Dan joined the agency in 2014 and is licensed in Ohio for Property, Casualty, Life, Health and Annuities. Dan is an Auglaize County native who has been a small business owner since 2002 along with working at G.A. Wintzer and Son Co. He is an Ohio State University graduate with a diversified background from agriculture to business. Dan and his wife, Brandi, enjoy raising their children, Alyssa and Kaelyn, in rural Wapakoneta.


Stephanie Winegardner, Senior Account Advisor

Stephanie has been with the agency since 1995 and holds State of Ohio licenses for Property, Casualty, Life and Health Insurance. She is well equipped to advise clients in all aspects of coverages and assist in evaluating insurance risks. In Stephanie’s spare time, she enjoys her family along with being active in her church and community.


Summer Shafer, Customer Service Agent

Summer joined the agency in 1999 and holds an Ohio Property and Casualty Insurance license. She is a graduate and longtime resident of Waynesfield and enjoys working with people, shopping garage sales and spending time by the pool.


Jill Steinke, Customer Service Agent

Jill, who is a graduate of Wapakoneta City Schools, came to our agency in 2005 after graduating from the University of Northwestern Ohio. She has a State of Ohio license for Property and Casualty. Jill enjoys spending time with her family and friends, is active in photography and scrapbooking and is an avid fan of NASCAR and the OSU Buckeyes.


Andrea Turner, Customer Service Agent

Andrea, who is a graduate of Waynesfield-Goshen High School and the Art Institute of Ohio-Cincinnati, joined the team in 2015. She completed her license with the State of Ohio for Property and Casualty Insurance. Andrea enjoys spending time with family and friends along with hobbies such as scrapbooking, decorating and crafting. Andrea and her husband, Brice, have two children, Lanson and Evie, residing outside of Waynesfield.